Carrie Underwood threatens to quit American Idol unless producers boost her salary and back off fan backlash drama: report

Carrie Underwood may not be returning for another season of American Idol, and insiders say producers are panicking.

The country superstar, who shot to fame after winning the show in 2005, took over as a judge this season following Katy Perry’s exit. But according to a report from GLOBE Magazine, her first year in the judging seat was far from smooth—and now she’s delaying her contract renewal.

“She’s unsure if she wants to continue,” one production insider shared. While producers are eager to lock her in, Underwood has yet to give them an answer.

Fans criticize her judging style and salary issues erupt

Underwood reportedly faced criticism for being “too soft” on contestants. Fellow judge Lionel Richie allegedly accused her of letting weak singers slide, saying she praised them for being “cute” rather than talented. Fans online called her “boring” and questioned her ability to deliver tough feedback.

Adding to the tension is her paycheck. Underwood’s salary is said to be half of what former judge Katy Perry earned—roughly $25 million a year. A show insider said that disparity doesn’t sit well with her, especially since she’s now carrying a significant share of the show’s emotional weight.

“She got a lot of backlash, and she’s not used to that,” another source said. “Carrie’s always been adored by fans. This was a shock to her system.”

The Before He Cheats singer recently posted about the emotional toll, admitting she hates rejecting contestants. She wrote that saying “no” was the “worsty worst worstest” part of her job, which some viewers felt reinforced her “too nice” image.

Producers want a decision, Carrie wants more

Despite the rough start, network executives still believe in Underwood’s star power. They’re reportedly willing to give her another shot—but only if she commits soon. One insider revealed producers want a clear answer and don’t want to be strung along.

“They know Carrie can grow into the role,” said a source. “But dragging out the negotiations is not a good look for a show this big.”

While Underwood hasn’t officially demanded a raise, insiders believe she’s holding out for better terms. The feeling behind the scenes is that if she does return, she’ll push for more money and creative input.

Those close to her worry she’s battling an “internal war” over whether this new chapter is truly right for her. “Carrie needs to tread carefully,” one source warned. “If she comes off too demanding, it might hurt her reputation more than help.”

For now, American Idol fans and executives alike are holding their breath, waiting to see if the show’s golden girl will stick around—or walk away for good.