Cowboys Expected to Replace Dak Prescott in 2026 with a Big-Name Quarterback in Blockbuster Move

The Dallas Cowboys, one of the most storied franchises in the National Football League (NFL), are reportedly planning a major transition at the quarterback position.

According to league insiders, the team is expected to move on from veteran signal-caller Dak Prescott following the 2025 season and pursue a high-profile replacement in a blockbuster move that could reshape the franchise’s future.

This potential decision marks a pivotal moment for the Cowboys, who have been led by Prescott since 2016.

With his contract set to expire after the 2025 season, speculation is mounting that the team may be looking to take a different direction under center.

In this in-depth analysis, we explore the reasons behind the rumored decision, potential quarterback options, and the impact such a move could have on the Cowboys’ long-term prospects.

Dak Prescott’s Tenure with the Cowboys

Prescott, a fourth-round pick in the 2016 NFL Draft, quickly emerged as the Cowboys’ franchise quarterback, leading the team to multiple playoff appearances.

Despite regular-season success, he has been unable to guide the team past the divisional round of the playoffs, which has led to criticism from fans and analysts alike.

The 2024 and 2025 seasons will be critical for Prescott’s legacy in Dallas. If he fails to lead the Cowboys deep into the postseason, team owner Jerry Jones and the front office may feel compelled to explore other options at the position.

While Prescott has shown flashes of brilliance, questions remain about his ability to elevate the team in crucial moments.

Why the Cowboys May Be Looking to Move On

Several factors are driving the speculation that the Cowboys are considering a change at quarterback:

1. Contract Situation

Prescott’s current deal, signed in 2021, is set to expire after the 2025 season. If the Cowboys are hesitant to commit to another long-term contract with a high salary cap hit, they may explore alternative options.

2. Playoff Performance

While Prescott has consistently put up strong numbers in the regular season, his playoff record (just two postseason wins as of 2024) remains a sticking point. Dallas, a team with Super Bowl aspirations, may seek a quarterback with a proven track record in high-pressure games.

3. Cap Space and Roster Building

The Cowboys are a team built around expensive star players, including wide receiver CeeDee Lamb and linebacker Micah Parsons. A younger, more affordable quarterback could allow the team to allocate resources to other key areas.

4. The Window to Win

With an elite defense and dynamic offensive weapons, the Cowboys are in win-now mode.

If team leadership believes a different quarterback can maximize their chances of a Super Bowl run, they may be willing to make a bold move.

Potential Quarterback Replacements

If the Cowboys do part ways with Prescott, they will have several intriguing options to consider. Here are some potential candidates to take over in 2026:

1. Caleb Williams (Chicago Bears)

The No. 1 overall pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, Caleb Williams is widely regarded as a generational talent.

If the Bears struggle in the next two seasons and undergo a front-office shakeup, Williams could become available via trade.

2. C.J. Stroud (Houston Texans)

Stroud had an outstanding rookie campaign in 2023 and is viewed as one of the league’s brightest young quarterbacks.

However, if circumstances change in Houston, Dallas could explore a trade to acquire the former Ohio State star.

3. Patrick Mahomes (Kansas City Chiefs)

While highly unlikely, some speculate that if Mahomes ever became available due to a major shakeup in Kansas City, Jerry Jones would do everything in his power to bring him to Dallas.

4. A 2026 Draft Prospect

If the Cowboys prefer a long-term approach, they could target a quarterback in the 2026 NFL Draft.

Players like Arch Manning (assuming he enters the draft by then) or another highly-touted prospect could be on their radar.

5. A Veteran Free Agent

If Dallas wants an experienced quarterback, they could consider targeting someone like Kirk Cousins, Russell Wilson, or another veteran available in free agency at that time.

What This Means for the Cowboys’ Future

1. Franchise Direction

A decision to move on from Prescott would signal a major shift in the franchise’s vision.

While Prescott has been a stabilizing force, the Cowboys could be looking for a quarterback capable of taking them to the next level.

2. Financial Flexibility

If Dallas decides not to offer Prescott a massive extension, they could gain financial flexibility to bolster their roster elsewhere.

This could be crucial in retaining top defensive stars and adding depth at other key positions.

3. Fan and Media Reaction

Cowboys fans are passionate and divided on Prescott. While some believe he deserves more time, others feel it’s time for a change.

The team’s decision, whichever direction it takes, will undoubtedly dominate NFL headlines.

4. Pressure on Jerry Jones and Mike McCarthy

If the Cowboys fail to make a deep playoff run in 2024 or 2025, both Jerry Jones and head coach Mike McCarthy will face immense pressure.

A quarterback change could be seen as a last-ditch effort to maximize their championship window.