When “American Idol” judges Carrie Underwood, Luke Bryan, and Lionel Richie delivered their decision on which four contestants would round out the top 14 on April 21, 2025, Baylee Littrell did not make the cut after performing John Legend’s “All of Me.”

That was a shocker for lots of Backstreet Boys fans who’ve been cheering on the son of BSB member Brian Littrell since he confirmed his 22-year-old son had auditioned. Baylee made it all the way to the top 20, but both Underwood and Bryan acknowledged that his elimination is likely tough on his dad and his fans.

Baylee Littrell Says There Was ‘A Lot of Pre-Judgment’ About Him

Moments after the top 14 was finalized, Underwood acknowledged to “Entertainment Tonight” that she was aware Brian, who attended and even sang during his son’s audition, was likely a bit upset with the judges over their decision.

When the outlet asked Underwood about him possibly being upset, she replied, “Um, don’t think it didn’t cross my mind!”

Bryan also weighed in, telling “ET” that “there may be a Backstreet Boy that’s a little disappointed, and a lot of Backstreet Boy fans.”

Baylee, meanwhile, told “ET” after he got cut, “It’s been a very long journey, a lot of pre-judgment, and now, uh, these guys gave me my chance. Just blessed to be here. Backstreet’s back.”

Though Baylee received tons of support from BSB fans, he also faced a great deal of criticism from “Idol” viewers who labeled him a “nepo baby,” riding on the coattails of his famous dad.

Backstreet Boys & Their Fans Flood Baylee Littrell With Support

Baylee’s famous dad responded to his son’s April 22 Instagram post about being cut from the competition, writing, “Bubba I am and always will be in your corner. You’d are so strong and so very talented, and inspire me every day. It’s never the end, only the beginning for so many to be blessed by your gifts….. you killed it last night. 🔥❤️”

Brian’s wife, Leighanne Littrell, also weighed in on their son’s post, disappointed that “Idol” didn’t upload his final performance to its social media pages.

“I wish they would have posted last nights performance,” she wrote. “You killed it bubba! SO SO VERY PROUD! You are a true artist, no bells and whistles needed! Keep on keepin on! I can’t wait for what’s to come!”

Another Backstreet Boy, Kevin Richardson, wrote on Baylee’s post, “So glad you got to experience this. Proud of you young man. Your journey has just begun… ❤️”

BSB fans also flooded Baylee’s post with support, including one who wrote, “So proud of you Baylee! It got your name and music out for the world to see! 😍 You killed it! Here’s to much success and more music! 😍”