A new wave of shock has rippled through the DC fandom, and this time, it’s not coming from a trailer, a casting rumor, or a vague studio tease.

According to multiple behind-the-scenes sources, Henry Cavill and Ben Affleck are reportedly prepared to return as Superman and Batman—but only under one uncompromising condition: Zack Snyder must be back at the helm.

The revelation has reignited conversations many believed were long buried. For years, fans were told the Snyderverse was finished, closed, and creatively abandoned. Yet now, whispers from inside the industry suggest that the story may not be over after all.

In fact, it may have been waiting for the right moment to resurface.

Quiet Talks, Loud Implications

Sources close to DC claim that “quiet, high-level discussions” have already begun. These are not public negotiations or press-friendly announcements, but internal conversations happening behind closed doors—conversations driven by one undeniable force: relentless fan pressure.

The #RestoreTheSnyderVerse movement never truly disappeared. Even after studio shake-ups, leadership changes, and creative reboots, fan campaigns continued across social media, conventions, and streaming platforms. What once seemed like wishful thinking is now being discussed again in executive offices, according to insiders.

One source described the current situation as “a pressure cooker that’s been building for years.”

“The studio may have moved on publicly,” the source said, “but the audience never did.”

Henry Cavill’s Unfinished Superman

Henry Cavill’s connection to Superman has always gone deeper than a single casting decision. Those close to the actor say he remains deeply attached to his vision of the character—a grounded, emotionally complex Superman struggling to balance godlike power with human vulnerability.

Cavill’s portrayal in Man of Steel divided audiences at the time, but over the years, it has gained a strong following. Fans now praise the performance for its seriousness, restraint, and emotional weight—qualities that many feel are missing from more lighthearted interpretations.

According to sources, Cavill has never rejected a return outright. Instead, he has been selective.

“He doesn’t want a cameo,” one insider explained. “He doesn’t want a soft reboot that ignores what came before. If Superman comes back, it has to mean something.”

That “something,” sources say, is Zack Snyder.

Ben Affleck’s Batman: A Chapter Never Closed

Ben Affleck’s relationship with Batman has been equally complex. Publicly, Affleck has spoken about the personal challenges he faced during his time as the Dark Knight. Yet privately, insiders claim he never truly closed the chapter on his battle-worn, morally scarred Bruce Wayne.

Affleck’s Batman—older, darker, and visibly exhausted by years of fighting crime—was one of the most radical interpretations the character had seen on screen. While controversial at first, it has since gained renewed appreciation, particularly after Zack Snyder’s Justice League reframed the character’s arc.

“Affleck always felt there was more story to tell,” a source revealed. “His Batman was never meant to be a one-note character. There was redemption coming.”

According to the leak, Affleck’s willingness to return is tied directly to creative control and narrative continuity—both of which he believes only Snyder can provide.

Why Zack Snyder Is the Non-Negotiable Factor

At the center of it all stands Zack Snyder.

For Cavill and Affleck, Snyder is not just a director, but the architect of a shared cinematic vision. Insiders suggest that both actors feel the emotional and thematic foundation of their characters was uniquely understood by Snyder—and that without him, returning would feel hollow.

The Snyderverse, sources say, was never designed as isolated films, but as a long-form mythological arc. Its abrupt interruption left character journeys unresolved, themes unfinished, and fans deeply frustrated.

“The plan was bigger than people realized,” one source said. “And it was never completed.”

A Fanbase That Refused to Let Go

What makes this leak especially explosive is the role fans have played in keeping the conversation alive. Unlike many franchise controversies that fade with time, the Snyderverse debate only grew louder.

Streaming numbers for Zack Snyder’s Justice League, ongoing social media campaigns, and continued demand at fan events have made it impossible for studios to fully ignore. Executives may not publicly acknowledge it, but sources say the data tells a clear story: interest never vanished.

“This isn’t nostalgia,” a media analyst noted. “It’s sustained engagement.”

The Studio Dilemma

For DC, the situation presents both an opportunity and a risk.

On one hand, reuniting Cavill, Affleck, and Snyder could trigger massive fan excitement and global attention. On the other, it could complicate existing plans, timelines, and creative directions.

Sources stress that nothing is finalized. No contracts have been signed. No announcements are imminent. But the fact that discussions are happening at all marks a dramatic shift from the narrative that the Snyderverse was “dead and buried.”

The Final Piece Before the Explosion?

The leak has left fans asking one question: is this the final domino before a major DC upheaval?

Insiders caution that expectations should remain measured. Studios move slowly, and corporate realities often override creative passion. Still, the alignment of fan demand, actor interest, and unresolved storylines has created a rare moment—one that DC may not get again.

“The Snyderverse was never dead,” one source concluded. “It was paused. Waiting.”

Whether that wait is about to end remains uncertain. But one thing is clear: the DC universe is standing at a crossroads, and what happens next could redefine its future.

If this leak proves accurate, the return of Superman and Batman under Zack Snyder wouldn’t just be a casting decision—it would be a seismic event. One capable of shaking the entire DC universe to its core.

And if it doesn’t happen? The pressure will only grow louder.